This Film is Available in Critical Audio

Field NotesDarkness

A quick note about this section

The creative process is one of constant discovery. You’re always looking for new ways of seeing, thinking and doing. Along the way, some things stand out and we put them in our Field Notes. This is a collection of ideas, places, people and things that we’ve found that we think are worth sharing and that all loosely fit within the theme of the issue.

Blind film critic Tommy Edison reviews films for those seeking entertainment beyond sight.

Written by
Keith Francis

“I think the unsung hero in this movie is the writing and editing. They tell this story in such a way that you don’t know where you’re going and you don’t know where you’ve been, but it really keeps you on the edge of your seat.”

That’s Tommy Edison reviewing the film Memento — the famously complex breakout debut of Christopher Nolan — in which the entire story is told backwards. It is a film that challenges even the most focused audiences. What makes Edison’s review noteworthy is the fact that he is blind, only able to perceive changes in light intensity.

Known as the Blind Film Critic, Edison was born with an underdeveloped optic nerve, though his blindness has never been a matter of concern to him. Before becoming a film critic, he worked as a radio traffic reporter in Bridgeport, Connecticut, by listening to police scanners. Then, prompted by a barroom goof in 2011, he decided to review the film Scream 4 and post it to YouTube. Shortly afterwards, it was tweeted by Roger Ebert.

Watching Edison’s reviews, it’s impressive how perceptive he’s able to be, producing surprisingly well-rounded critiques. In reviewing Star Trek: Beyond, he focuses on the performances of each actor, going so far as to say, “I felt like Simon Pegg played himself, but I really enjoyed every time he was on screen. He always had a good line.”

The one thing that I think is so funny is that people that I’ve known for my entire life have never asked me the questions that people ask me on YouTube.

Thirteen million views in, Edison has become a figurehead of the community and is a frequent speaker at events around the globe. He launched a second YouTube channel, The Tommy Edison Experience, with a focus on addressing the misconceptions about blindness, mediating the uncomfortable and awkward with humourous anecdotes and observations. It’s become a fertile forum for advocacy and resistance to socially imposed stereotypes, each question and answer reconceptualizing what it’s like to live with a perceived disability.

“The one thing that I think is so funny is that people that I’ve known for my entire life have never asked me the questions that people ask me on YouTube … If I say something’s off limits, then all of a sudden, people are going to start to be afraid. If people can’t ask, they can’t learn.”

While it might seem novel for someone without the use of sight to review film, Edison is a reminder that an experience can be perceived in countless different ways, and that each is just as valid.

Next time you’re watching Goodfellas, one of Edison’s favourites, consider starting the movie with your eyes closed — hear the vibrato of Tony Bennett fading in, underneath, the smooth warmth of a brass band, and then the gravely, low voice of Ray Liotta speaks: “To me, being a gangster was better than being President of the United States.”

Keith Francis

Keith Francis is an interdisciplinarian, phenomenologist, strategist, researcher and change agent, Keith has worked as a professional in several design mediums such as wayfinding, human factors outcomes accessibility, and brand design strategy.

Preparing is Half the Adventure

Modern-day discoverer Adam Shoalts discusses risk taking, remoteness, and the role of research in his latest four-month solo trek through the Canadian Arctic into areas still untouched by human footprints.

Read More

Reading in the Dark

Ten must-read books to get you through the night.

Read More


A mirror for the "daily me"

Read More


Thinner, greener, smarter

Read More


Epic wins, every day

Read More


Colour for the colour blind

Read More

Gravity Light

A new class of lightweight

Read More

Awake in the Amazon

A traveller shares his deep and incomplete reflection on an ayahuasca trip.

Read More

Wearing Black

A Photo Essay by Nick Kozak

Read More

Missing and Murdered

Julian Brave NoiseCat interviews award-winning journalist Connie Walker about her podcast that brings light to one of Canada's darkest issues.

Read More

Chasing Totality

The most vivid memory I have of an eclipse is one of deep anxiety.

Read More

Dark Patterns

In today's digitally driven culture, where we share more about ourselves than ever before, companies are finding new, subtle ways to tap into an age-old marketing opportunity — our insecurity.

Read More

Changing the Conversation

Three YouTube creators are working to destigmatize their culture and maybe even learn a thing or two about themselves in the process.

Read More

Embracing Our Dark Reality

A collective of writers, artists, and thinkers is exploring the darkest realities of our time.

Read More

Preserving the Night Sky

Two astronomers discuss why the night sky we see today is different from what our grandparents saw.

Read More

Saving Endangered Languages

How one Mohawk community is reclaiming culture by revitalizing its mother tongue.

Read More

The Night Shift

Four Torontonians share the ins and outs of working outside the nine-to-five.

Read More

The Dark Arts

Artist Kent Monkman subverts colonial myths and First Nations representation in his sesquicentennial exhibition.

Read More

Having Fun Watching Others Having Fun

Twitch has built an unlikely new platform for online entertainment.

Read More